I know it’s been a long time since my last post and I apologize.

In the mean time, I was doing quite a bit of Excel programming and that’s the experience I want to talk about. I didn’t know much about Excel before starting. I have done VB, VBScript before so that came as no surprise. I also knew Excel is used quite a lot in the financial community, so I was keen to get some exposure to it.
After almost a year of development, ranging from VBA, plugin development (COM addin + Automation addin – DDE) and RTD, I can say, I have mixed feelings.

The overall experience I’m taking from this is that Excel is not a mature environment for development and the experience can be quite frustrating. It is almost decent at VBA, but when you start with addins, RTD, it all leaves a slightly bitter taste in your mouth. And here’s why, all the reasons listed one after the other:

1. Excel is single threaded. This has several implications:
a. You cannot call into Excel when it’s busy, RPC calls fail, for this you have to retry, or sometimes you get the dreaded dialog telling you that the STA is busy
b. It’s slower than it should be. Cannot take advantage of multi-processors
c. Can get easily into a “frozen” state, when long operations have to be done on the UI thread
d. Operations need to be marshalled into the STA, which is extremely slow and I do mean extremely

In Excel 2007 they have introduced multi-threading. However, they have also changed the interface, introducing the ribbon interface and alienating the entire financial community. No one is moving to Excel 2007 for that reason.

2. Error handling is extremely poor

When something happens, you don’t get a clear error, but instead a general error of what happens. Many APIs return the same errors and the errors are not documented.
This is truly a killer, and it’s true with the whole Excel object model. A very very big issue.

3. The addin frameworks are all a bit of mess

There are 3 main types of addins:
a. COM addin, you can implement UI elements, but no UDFs
b. Automation addins, you can implement UDFs, but no UI elements
c. RTD servers, you can implement a very limited interface to update data, a pull-push hybrid, but no access to the Excel object model at all

So, let’s say you want to implement an addin which has a UI menu with some functionality, provides a UDF, which operates asynchronously. Then you need a combination of potentially all three addins in one, maybe add VBA xla on top of that.

4. Some operations don’t work from addins, only from VBA, or only from some context, or only if the VBA_E_IGNORE is not set, or if other black box conditions are set

Again, lack of documentation makes it really difficult to develop. It’s a trial & error approach which works most of the time.
You always face the problem where your addin works most of the time, unless the user does something which you didn’t expect and tested.

5. Pushing data into Excel is very difficult

Either Excel is busy, or sets itself into VBA_E_IGNORE when a dialog is present, or operations fail because you’re in edit mode.
This problem was addressed by the introduction of the RTD framework

6. Excel is still buggy and it can crash

If you do certain operations, you might hit a bug in Excel and crash it. It crashes because bugs in Excel, but your addin/VBA are triggering, so you look like a culprit.

7. Excel doesn’t perform very well when you have big workbooks with a lot of data

8. Very difficult to debug problems in Excel, or weirdness like above, because Excel is a black box

Still, Excel is loved in the financial community, because it makes non-programmers more productive by its operations. It’s an easy way to present, format data which can be refreshed and kept up to date.
Yet, for developers, it can be a nightmare.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: